PhoneDog ( a nice site for comparing or dogfights ) published one of the famous dogfights, comparing the Nokia Lumia 900 on AT&T vs the HTC One S on T-Mobile USA. The video shows while Android is the king of customization, the wealth of choice and confusing limitations can quickly make this a curse rather than blessing. See the videos and then decide what was the hullabolo about !! Part1 Part 2
For me it boils down to the user. Their style of usage. Android so far has worked bets for me. I got it for my dad, pure fail. He is loving his Focus.